Add Action to reply message to whatsapp and other apps also (already been implemented)

Dhruv Chauhan

New member
To Reply a whatsapp message without opening chat, We have to fake UI interaction and for many messages we lost control over schedule reply messages... So i would like to have a feature that replies to whatsapp Messages directly just as "Auto responder Message to whatsapp" Application .
 
Last edited:

Dimlos

Well-known member
It may be possible to use Auto reply in Notification Listener, but WhatsApp does not seem to be comfortable with auto-replies, and in the past we have run into a situation where people who set up auto-replies using this plugin have been unable to use it after a while.

I am not sure of the details, but it is possible that restrictions have been placed on accounts, which would make it very difficult to implement such a feature.

Telegram is very generous with automated processing and I have not heard of any restrictions being placed on it. If you need auto-replies, it is likely that you should use Telegram.
 

Dhruv Chauhan

New member
It may be possible to use Auto reply in Notification Listener, but WhatsApp does not seem to be comfortable with auto-replies, and in the past we have run into a situation where people who set up auto-replies using this plugin have been unable to use it after a while.

I am not sure of the details, but it is possible that restrictions have been placed on accounts, which would make it very difficult to implement such a feature.

Telegram is very generous with automated processing and I have not heard of any restrictions being placed on it. If you need auto-replies, it is likely that you should use Telegram.
I tried using notifications listener here it was tested... 👇


It's not a good practice to change whole platform Directly from WhatsApp to telegram just for auto reply, As far as i know replying from notification is not restricted much , You can refer "Autoresponder For Whatsapp" Application that simply works for it.
 

Dimlos

Well-known member
It looks like you have put together a rather complicated macro. Please refer to the following thread @FrameXX recipe should make it easy to set up an auto-reply macro.

@OscariBot worked normally for 2 days, but after that it didn't seem to work no matter what I did.
It also describes the Autoresponder For X app, I guess it's inevitable that people have different opinions because different people want different things.
 

Attachments

  • telegram_response.jpg
    telegram_response.jpg
    386.4 KB · Views: 19
Last edited:

Dhruv Chauhan

New member
It looks like you have put together a rather complicated macro. Please refer to the following thread @FrameXX recipe should make it easy to set up an auto-reply macro.

@OscariBot worked normally for 2 days, but after that it didn't seem to work no matter what I did.
It also describes the Autoresponder For X app, I guess it's inevitable that people have different opinions because different people want different things.
those plugins isn't working for auto reply now & One is there named "Auto Notification" but it takes too much random time to reply a single message.
 

Dimlos

Well-known member
I don't have time to test it now, but I'm making sure the telegram auto-reply works reliably before I write...
 

Dimlos

Well-known member
Did you read the thread I linked to carefully, and don't you see that it says whatsapp could be limited?
I have no intention of verifying such a risk and I don't think any risky feature will ever be implemented in MacroDroid.
 

OscariBot

Active member
The plugins has absolute limitations on WhatsApp... It seems Whatsapp is somehow monitoring and scanning for this pluggin.

Like I said it works perfectly for 2day wen I implement it and then suddenly stop without any cause.
Then I switch to telegram n it's working till date. It's over 4months now.

Here is the scariest part... Do you know after reading this thread 4days ago I decided to give same Whatsapp a try again, guess what? It auto responded for 72hours and then my account was blocked. Hence it's obvious to say Whatsapp really frown at auto responder.

Whatstasker is the pluggin to use if you really want to auto respond Whatsapp but this pluggin require root access. It's has been working for me for over 5yrs and it's still working on my rooted device.
 

OscariBot

Active member
But here's the irony of it all....

There's an app call WhatsappAutoresponder this app have been working for over 7yrs till date for Whatsapp and just like Notification-Listener it doesn't need root access.
Yet Whatsapp detect and stop Notification Listener and allow WhatsappAutoresponder till date.

Downside of WhatsappAutoresponder is that unlike the rooted version you can't use macrodroid to process your input b4 responding... and that alone is a turn off for me.
 

Dhruv Chauhan

New member
Did you read the thread I linked to carefully, and don't you see that it says whatsapp could be limited?
I have no intention of verifying such a risk and I don't think any risky feature will ever be implemented in MacroDroid.
I get your concerns, but just wanted to share that MacroDroid recently rolled out a cool feature – replying to WhatsApp chats without any hassle named "Notification Reply". I've been using it, and honestly, it's been smooth sailing. No UI interactions needed, and it works like a charm. So, no worries about any risky stuff getting in the way. Cheers !
 

OscariBot

Active member
I get your concerns, but just wanted to share that MacroDroid recently rolled out a cool feature – replying to WhatsApp chats without any hassle named "Notification Reply". I've been using it, and honestly, it's been smooth sailing. No UI interactions needed, and it works like a charm. So, no worries about any risky stuff getting in the way. Cheers !
I thought it uses UI interaction
 

Dhruv Chauhan

New member
I thought it uses UI interaction
No, the process doesn't depend on UI interactions, it seamlessly executes notification actions in the background, identical to functions such as "Reply" and "Mute" buttons. This functionality is particularly advantageous for me to automating responses, facilitating an effortless setup for auto-reply using a dictionary variable. The use of a key as a trigger word and the associated value as the reply text adds a layer of efficiency to meet my specific requirements.
 

OscariBot

Active member
No, the process doesn't depend on UI interactions, it seamlessly executes notification actions in the background, identical to functions such as "Reply" and "Mute" buttons. This functionality is particularly advantageous for me to automating responses, facilitating an effortless setup for auto-reply using a dictionary variable. The use of a key as a trigger word and the associated value as the reply text adds a layer of efficiency to meet my specific requirements.
But this is in beta stage... Can u share a macro?
 
Top